After pointing out that I think this is a positive move by the boy scouts.... you know the whole anti-discrimination thing is a good value to teach children. The counter argument by this brilliant debater was to give a few biblical reasons why gays in the boy scouts will destroy the organisation and and and. His argument was not a good one, but I was prepared to entertain it (for the whole argument see the full transcript below). So this was my reply.
I will ask you one question. If homosexuality is so wrong according to the bible. Why did God create homosexual animals besides humans? if you can answer that....well then you are proving the existence of a god and you can get it published in Nature/Science
To which he replied:
God did not create homosexual animals. Animal behavior is not the same as human beings anyway. As to your desire for "proof," the real question is whether you can prove that "in the beginning nothing created everything that is," or that this ordered and highly complicated world could come as a complete result of an explosion in space. God exists. He is real. True science proves it....over and over.......
Then I said and this is where it gets interesting.